Happy Sunday! Great time for confession, right? Right. So, here we go:
I am not a fan of contemporary Christian music. I wasn’t raised with it, I have no tradition that points me towards it, and praise songs in particular do not move me. I find them shallow, to be honest.
But I love music, and I particularly love music that makes me think. The first outwardly Christian music I ever bought was from Jars of Clay. Musically exciting and not remotely shallow, Jars was a terrible, terrible place to start my Christian music journey. Outside of a couple other bands (Future of Forestry being one of them), I never found a band that matched what Jars was doing. I soon figured out there was a reason for that–contemporary Chrstian music largely does not abide the deep, questioning music Jars of Clay produced on the regular. They haven’t made new music in 10 years, and it’s been about that long since I heard a song in the genre that I genuinely liked.
But, I do like music that reflects my values.
What I have started doing is collecting songs by secular artists I do like that have a Christian theme, or that could be easily heard that way (all art can be manipulated to fit the viewer/listener). Below are a few I really love.
(I’m not listing any Jars of Clay songs here because they pretty much all fit the bill, but if anyone is unfamiliar with Jars and would like some recommendations for where to start, let me know and I’ll post a list. [Full disclosure: the lead singer/songwriter from Jars, Dan Haseltine, is one of the composers on my movie, but I only met Dan recently and I’ve been a fan of jars since 1996.]
Also, I’m including U2 here even though they’re one of the most Christian bands out there. Their lyrics can be a bit esoteric, so I’m listing songs from them that are more blatant in their themes.)
This selection doesn’t shy away from songs that are just as much about doubt as they are about faith. I find doubt in the context of faith to be strengthening and very much worth contemplating. We all experience it, and there’s nothing to be gained from pretending otherwise–and a lot to be gained from dealing with it head on.
Again, this is just a sample. I may drop more in the comments.
Kingdom Come – Coldplay
Until the End of the World – U2
On the Floor – Brandon Flowers
Get Me Right – Dashboard Confessional
A Certain Type of Girl – The Airborne Toxic Event
No Hard Feelings – The Avett Brothers
Let Your Heart Hold Fast – Fort Atlantic
Peace on Earth – U2
How It Ends – DeVotchKa
Open Arms – Elbow
Whispers in the Dark – Mumford & Sons
Morning Has Broken – Cat Stevens
The Man Comes Around – Johnny Cash
Man of God – Neil Diamond
Moment of Surrender – U2
Let There Be Morning – The Perishers
I Came to Believe – Johnny Cash
If you’ve got any others that fit, I’d love to hear it in the comments. There’s more out there for sure.
Originally published on Facebook on 7/16/23